What are the differences between PTFE and LCP flexible circuit board substrates? A comparison table of Dk/Df dielectric loss, processing difficulty, and high-frequency transmission selection.

電子實驗室工作台上高頻軟性電路板特寫,對比呈現金黃色 LCP 基板與乳白色 PTFE 複合基板微帶線結構

With AI servers frequently adopting PCIe 6.0/7.0 and 112G/224G SerDes, networking equipment upgrading to 800G/1.6T switches, and the widespread adoption of 5G millimeter-wave (mmWave) antenna modules (AiP), high-speed electronic signals are undergoing rigorous physical limits. As signal frequencies jump from 2.4GHz to 10GHz, 28GHz, and even above 40GHz, the polyimide (PI) substrates commonly used in traditional flexible printed circuit boards (FPCs) suffer from excessive dielectric loss and high water absorption, leading to severe signal attenuation, waveform distortion, and eye diagram closure, which no longer meet system specifications.

The focus of this revolution in high-frequency substrate materials is the head-to-head competition between two flagship materials: polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, commonly known as Teflon) and liquid crystal polymer (LCP), as well as modified polyimide (MPI) as a compromise. The core conclusion from the engineering perspective is very clear:

  • PTFE is the absolute king of electrical losses.It has extremely low loss (dielectric loss factor $D_f approx 0.0010$) in the range of 10GHz to 40GHz, but its extremely low surface free energy makes it very difficult to bond with copper foil. In addition, it is prone to "cold flow" creep deformation when subjected to pressure, and the hot pressing processing temperature is as high as 350°C or more, making mass production yield control extremely expensive.
  • LCP is a key component that balances multi-layering and moisture-wicking protection.Its water absorption rate is less than 0.04% (only a fraction of that of traditional PI), and $D_f$ maintains an excellent level of 0.0020 to 0.0025. The hot pressing temperature (approximately 280°C to 310°C) makes it more feasible for multilayer board stacking. However, its rigid rod-shaped molecules are very easy to orient themselves during film blow molding and extrusion, causing severe anisotropy, resulting in mismatch of the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) in the longitudinal and transverse directions and processing warping.

How to achieve the best balance between high-frequency electrical performance, manufacturing yield, and BOM cost? This article will start from the physical mechanism of signal attenuation, provide a complete specification parameter comparison table spanning 10GHz to 40GHz, deeply analyze the surface modification bottleneck of PTFE and the molecular orientation anisotropy of LCP, and sort out the selection judgment logic of AI server transmission lines and antenna modules.

The physical mechanism of high-frequency signal attenuation: Why must traditional PI signals be phased out above 10GHz?

In low-frequency digital circuits, the transmission loss of a conductor is mainly determined by the DC resistance of the conductor itself. However, when the signal transmission rate increases to tens of GHz, the total transmission attenuation ($) of high-frequency electromagnetic waves is mainly composed of two components: conductor loss ($\alpha_c$) and dielectric loss ($\alpha_d$).

$$ \alpha_{\text{total}} = \alpha_c + \alpha_d $$

Conductor loss is affected by the skin effect and the surface roughness of the copper foil, and increases with the square root of the frequency (1/4T). Dielectric loss, on the other hand, is the heat dissipation generated by the repeated polarization of the polymer chain segments of the substrate by the high-frequency alternating electric field, and its theoretical calculation formula is as follows:

$$ \alpha_d \approx 27.3 \cdot \frac{f}{c} \cdot \sqrt{D_k} \cdot D_f \quad (\text{dB/m}) $$

Where $f$ is the signal frequency, $c$ is the speed of light, $D_k$ (dielectric constant) represents the material's ability to store electrical energy, and $D_f$ (dissipation factor / $\tan\delta$) represents the proportion of electromagnetic energy dissipated by the material in the form of heat.

As can be seen from the formula, dielectric loss increases linearly with frequency. At 1 GHz, dielectric loss accounts for less than 20% of the total loss; however, once the frequency reaches 10 GHz to 40 GHz, dielectric loss will account for more than 50% to 70% of the total signal loss.

Traditional flexible printed circuit boards (FPCBs) use polyimide (PI) substrates, whose molecular backbone contains highly polar PI rings and carbonyl groups. At 10 GHz, the $D_k$ loss is as high as 3.2–3.5, and the $D_f$ loss is even higher, reaching 0.015–0.020. Such enormous losses cause high-speed signals to degrade severely after only tens of centimeters of trace routing, making them unacceptable for eye diagram testing at the receiver.

An even more deadly, invisible killer is "moisture." Water molecules are extremely polar molecules, with a dielectric constant of approximately 70-80 $D_k and 0.15 $D_f at 10GHz. Traditional polyimide (PI) has a saturated water absorption rate as high as 1.5 % to 3.0 %. Once moisture is absorbed, the effective $D_k and $D_f of the flexible printed circuit board will drift drastically, leading to impedance mismatch in the transmission line and generating reflected noise. For a detailed explanation of the temperature resistance and dielectric stability of different engineering plastics under extreme operating conditions, please refer to the website.Thermal stability and material selection of high-temperature engineering plastics under extreme environmentsThis is precisely the underlying physical reason why high-frequency and high-speed applications must completely replace traditional PI.

PTFE vs LCP vs MPI Specification Comparison Table: Dk, Df, Moisture Absorption Rate and Hot Pressing Parameters

To assist hardware architects and circuit design engineers in quickly identifying the right specifications, the table below summarizes the key physical and dielectric parameters of four flexible circuit board substrate materials in the 10GHz–40GHz frequency band, based on the IPC-4204B specification and Rogers Corporation and Kuraray technical manuals:

Material typeDielectric constant Dk (10~40GHz)Dielectric loss Df (10~40GHz)Moisture absorption rate (%)Hot pressing temperature (°C)
PTFE (Teflon composite film)2.1 to 2.40.0009 ~ 0.0013< 0.01350 ~ 385
LCP (Liquid Crystal Polymer Thin Film)2.9 ~ 3.10.0020 ~ 0.0025< 0.04280 ~ 310
MPI (Modified Polyimide)3.1 to 3.30.0040 ~ 0.00600.5 ~ 0.8200 ~ 240
Traditional PI (standard polyimide)3.2 ~ 3.50.0150 ~ 0.02001.5 ~ 3.0180 ~ 220

Table Selection Judgment and Practical Critical Points: In terms of dielectric loss, PTFE has a loss of only one-fifteenth that of traditional PI, making it the material with the lowest transmission loss among the three. However, its hot-pressing temperature approaches 380°C, and its coefficient of thermal expansion is difficult to control. It is usually used for point-to-point transmission lines with few signal layers (1-2 layers), long line lengths, and extremely stringent loss requirements (such as coaxial jumpers or backplane jumpers). LCP, on the other hand, achieves a precise balance between loss (approx. 0.002$) and processability. In particular, its water absorption rate of less than 0.04% ensures that its dielectric performance hardly drifts during high-temperature and high-humidity (e.g., 85°C/85% RH) environmental testing, making it the preferred choice for multilayer flexible boards (4-8 layers or more) and antenna packaging modules. MPI, as an "economical retrofit material," can be processed entirely on traditional PI production lines and is suitable for use in the Sub-6GHz band or secondary interfaces with a transmission distance of less than 10 cm.

PTFE Flexible Circuit Board Substrate: The Cost of "Copper Foil Adhesion" and "Cold Flow Deformation" Behind Extreme Dielectric Loss

The polymer structure of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) consists of a carbon-carbon skeleton completely shielded by tightly surrounded highly electronegative fluorine atoms. The C–F bond energy is extremely high (approximately 485 kJ/mol) and has excellent symmetry, with almost no permanent dipole moment inside the molecule. This endows PTFE with two major physical properties: extremely low $D_k$ (approximately 2.1) and extremely low $D_f$ (approximately 0.001) due to its extremely low polarizability, and extremely low surface free energy (critical surface tension of only about 18 mN/m).

The extremely low surface free energy allows liquids to exhibit a very large contact angle on its surface (water contact angle exceeds 110°), which is an unparalleled advantage in non-stick coatings, but a disastrous obstacle in the flexible copper clad laminate (FCCL) manufacturing process.Copper foil is extremely difficult to adhere firmly to the PTFE surface..

If copper foil is directly laminated, its peel strength is typically below 0.3 N/mm, far below the industrial assembly standard (usually >0.8 N/mm), making it highly susceptible to delamination and board breakage under the high-temperature impact of reflow soldering. To improve the adhesion of copper foil, the industry must introduce special surface modification processes:

  1. Sodium Naphthalene EtchingThe strong reducing properties of sodium metal are used to remove fluorine atoms from the PTFE surface, forming a rough, carbon-rich active layer. However, this chemical solution is hazardous, and the treated surface is prone to oxidation and moisture absorption; therefore, copper foil lamination must be completed within a strict timeframe.
  2. Plasma treatmentThe substrate surface is bombarded with argon, oxygen or carbon tetrafluoride plasma to introduce micrometer-scale roughened pores and graft polar functional groups.

However, the deeper the surface modification, the slightly higher the dielectric loss will be. If a high-roughness copper foil (such as traditional electrolytic copper foil STD) is used for physical bonding, the microscopic cusps of the copper foil will exacerbate the high-frequency skin effect loss, offsetting the low-loss advantage of PTFE. Therefore, PTFE high-frequency substrates must be paired with expensive ultra-low profile copper foil (HVLP or RTF), which places extremely high demands on the modification technology.

Furthermore, pure PTFE exhibits significant "cold flow" (or creep), meaning that under normal temperature and pressure or screw-locking pressure, the molecular chains slowly slip and deform over time. This causes localized slight changes in the substrate thickness of the microstrip, thereby altering the characteristic impedance (causing a 50 $/Omega$ shift). To address this issue, commercial PTFE high-frequency substrates (such as the Rogers RT/duroid series) typically require filling with microfiber cloth or ceramic nanoparticles (such as silicon dioxide or titanium dioxide), which significantly increases the difficulty of achieving uniformity in thin film fabrication and controlling costs.

LCP Flexible Circuit Board Substrate: Ultra-low Moisture Absorption Advantage and Process Challenges of Molecular Orientation Anisotropy

Liquid crystal polymer (LCP) is a fully aromatic backbone thermoplastic polyester. In the molten state, its rigid rod-shaped molecular chain segments spontaneously exhibit a highly ordered nematic phase arrangement, which forms a self-reinforcing microfiber structure after cooling and solidification.

LCP's most commendable engineering advantage lies in its dense crystalline structure. This structure makes it extremely difficult for water molecules to penetrate its free volume.Saturated water absorption rate is less than 0.04%This means that regardless of whether the equipment is located in a tropical rainforest or a dry server room, the signal delay (propagation delay) and dielectric loss curves of the LCP flexible circuit board remain almost flat and will never deteriorate drastically due to environmental humidity.

However, the rigid rod-like molecular structure of LCP is a double-edged sword, bringing with it one of the most challenging problems in the field of flexible circuit board processing:Flow-induced anisotropy.

  • Mismatch in coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE)During melt extrusion film formation, LCP molecular chains tend to align parallel to the flow direction (Machine Direction, MD). This allows the film's CTE in the longitudinal (MD) direction to be as low as 10–16 ppm/°C (perfectly matching the 17 ppm/°C of copper foil); however, in the transverse (TD) and thickness (Z-axis) directions perpendicular to the flow, the CTE can soar to 50–150 ppm/°C.
  • Risk of warping and micropore breakageWhen FPCs undergo lead-free reflow soldering at 260°C, the large thermal expansion ratio along the Z-axis exerts severe tensile stress on the plated copper layer of the laser via walls, leading to via wall cracking or micro-via open circuits. Furthermore, the anisotropic stress release can cause severe PCB dimensional deformation and warpage.

To overcome the anisotropy of LCP, film suppliers (such as Japan's Kuraray and Murata, and Taiwan's Taihong and Damai R&D systems) must adopt a special blown film multi-axis rotating die process (Blown Film with Counter-Rotating Die) to forcibly break the single flow direction and make the molecular chains present an isotropic biaxial interlaced network structure in the plane.

In multilayer flexible circuit board lamination, the hot-pressing temperature window for LCP is extremely narrow (typically between 285°C and 305°C). At slightly lower temperatures, LCP cannot melt and achieve self-adhesive flow; exceeding the temperature by 5°C to 10°C causes the material to rapidly transform from a nematic phase to a homogeneous isotropic liquid, resulting in a sharp drop in melt viscosity. This leads to the extrusion and displacement of substrate traces and the collapse of dielectric thickness. This stringent tolerance in hot-pressing processes places extremely high demands on the temperature uniformity ($) of the lamination equipment. Similar trade-offs between substrate flatness and high-frequency transmission can be observed in advanced substrate and packaging applications.Flatness evaluation of advanced packaging and high-frequency signal transmission on glass substratesStructural comparison.

MPI (Modified Polyimide)'s Transitional Positioning: A Cost-Effective Trade-off from Sub-6GHz to 15GHz

Since PTFE is difficult and expensive to process, and the anisotropy of LCP films is not easy to control and the patents are concentrated in a few large Japanese manufacturers, the engineering community has developed modified polyimide (MPI).

The chemical modification pathway of MPI mainly involves introducing sterically hindered nonpolar fluorocarbon groups or alicyclic structures into the molecular backbone of polyimide, or reducing molecular polarizability through copolymerization. Simultaneously, adjusting the chemical structure reduces its free volume, suppressing the water absorption rate from 2% of traditional PI to approximately 0.5%–0.8%.

In terms of electrical performance, MPI exhibits a satisfactory compromise in the 10GHz–15GHz frequency band:

  • The dielectric constant $D_k$ is approximately 3.1 to 3.3.
  • The dielectric loss $D_f$ is reduced to 0.0040~0.0060.

Although MPI's $D_f$ is still about twice that of LCP, in the Sub-6GHz 5G band or in the internal wiring of mobile phones with a transmission length of less than 10 cm, the resulting absolute attenuation difference (usually less than 0.5 dB) is completely within the dynamic range compensation of the RF front-end chip.

The most important thing isManufacturing compatibility and economyMPI retains the chemical properties of traditional thermosetting polyimide. PCB manufacturers do not need to purchase high-temperature vacuum laminating machines costing millions of dollars each; they can directly utilize existing copper foil lamination, drilling, and cleaning production lines for mass production. Its overall manufacturing yield is over 901 TP3T, and the overall substrate cost is 201 TP3T to 301 TP3T cheaper than LCP. Therefore, MPI firmly occupies a mainstream transitional material position in consumer electronics and automotive secondary communication modules below 15GHz.

Selection Practices for High-Speed Jumpers and 5G Millimeter-Wave Antenna Modules in AI Servers

The selection of high-frequency flexible printed circuit board (FPCB) materials is not simply determined by "who has the lowest $D_f$," but rather by the architectural selection based on the actual hardware system's spatial geometry, transmission length, frequency upper limit, and bending requirements.

Signal frequency and transmission lengthSystem architecture limitations and challengesRecommended materialsCore Reasons and Selection Trade-offs
Sub-6GHz / below 15GHz (trace length < 10cm)Cost-sensitive, short-range mobile phone and vehicle signalsMPI (Modified Polyimide)Compatible with traditional PI production line equipment, yield >90% (%), and most competitive overall cost.
20GHz~112GHz (long distance 30~80cm)AI Server GPU/NVSwitch High-Speed Internal JumperPTFE micro coaxial cable (Twinax)Lowest dielectric loss (Df 0.001), significantly saving a critical 2-3 dB loss margin.
28GHz~39GHz 5G millimeter wave antennaHigh-density multilayer interconnects (4-8 layers), micro-blind viasLCP Multilayer Flexible Circuit BoardWith a saturated water absorption rate of <0.04%, it can be glue-free, self-fusing, multi-layered, moisture-resistant, and dimensionally stable.

1. High-speed transmission patch cord (Near-ASIC Cable / Flyover) inside the AI server

In high-end AI server racks represented by NVIDIA HGX, GB200, or AMD MI300, the SerDes connection speed between the GPU and NVSwitch has reached as high as 112Gbps or even 224Gbps PAM4, and the Nyquist frequency has reached as high as 28GHz to 56GHz.

If all signals are routed via copper traces within a large, multi-layered PCB backplane, even with expensive M7/M8 grade ultra-low loss materials, the insertion loss will still exceed the 30 dB budget when the trace length exceeds 30 cm. Therefore, server architectures have shifted to using "over-PCB flyover cables." Under this architecture:

2. 5G millimeter-wave antenna package module (Antenna-in-Package, AiP)

5G millimeter wave (28GHz, 39GHz) antenna modules must highly integrate RF chips, power management ICs, and array antennas into a very small module.

  • The module typically requires a high-density interconnect (HDI) structure of 4 to 8 layers, containing a large number of micro-blind vias and buried vias.
  • Here LCP becomes the overwhelming choiceDue to issues with high-temperature cold flow and residual adhesive from laser drilling, PTFE is almost impossible to stably produce high-yield microvia blind buried boards with more than 6 layers; while LCP has thermoplastic self-melting bonding capabilities, can complete adhesive-free multilayer lamination at around 290°C, and has extremely low water absorption, ensuring that mobile phone antennas exposed to the external environment maintain their resonant frequency without shifting in humid climates.

High-frequency material selection is not just about dielectric constant (Df): a comprehensive balance between dielectric stability, thermomechanical stress, and mass production yield.

From microwave theory in the laboratory to mass production lines in the factory, the selection of high-frequency and high-speed materials is essentially a "system-level compromise." Many novice designers easily fall into the trap of "only pursuing the lowest specification of $D_f$," only to encounter a serious yield Waterloo when they enter the prototype and trial production stage.

When making substrate selection decisions, the engineering team must review the following four engineering checkpoints in sequence:

  1. Dielectric stabilityThe study evaluated the drift amplitude of $D_k$ and $D_f$ within the operating temperature range ($ - 40°C to 105°C) and humidity variation (0°C to 90°C RH). If the material has a high water absorption rate, the excellent performance of $D_f$ under normal dry conditions will be rendered ineffective in humid environments.
  2. Thermo-mechanical ReliabilityConfirm the compatibility between the material's Z-axis CTE and the electroplated copper layer. Excessive thickness expansion can cause through-hole breakage during lead-free SMT reflow soldering, directly compromising the overall reliability of the system.
  3. Tooling & Process CompatibilityCheck whether the manufacturing end has high-temperature vacuum laminating machines, plasma surface treatment machines, and high-precision blind hole laser drilling equipment. If the use of PTFE causes the multilayer lamination yield to drop below 60%, the saved signal decibels will be completely swallowed up by the soaring manufacturing scrap costs.
  4. Supply Chain Security and Dual OriginThe patents for high-end LCP films and high-purity PTFE have long been controlled by American and Japanese chemical giants. Confirming a second supplier (such as Taiwan's progress in localization certification in the fields of FCCL and substrates) is a core consideration to ensure long-term mass production is not threatened by supply chain disruptions.

In the extreme races of high frequency and high speed, there is no perfect single material; only engineering decisions that achieve the best balance among dielectric loss, manufacturing tolerance, and mass production cost.

Recommended Posts